Critical Reflection 1: 

 

Driving question: What is the impact of technology on education and on us?

 

Description

I reflected on how technology influences education and everyday life. Over recent years, digital tools have become central to learning through online platforms, digital assessments, and constant device use. I considered my own experiences as a student and what I observe in others, especially how technology affects attention, learning habits, and digital skills.

Feelings

I initially felt grateful for the convenience technology brings. It makes learning flexible and accessible, especially when balancing study, work, and personal commitments. However, I also felt overwhelmed at times. Constant notifications, multitasking, and the pressure to stay connected can make learning feel scattered. These mixed feelings made me curious about what research actually says about technology’s impact.

Evaluation

Technology offers clear benefits. It supports communication, provides instant access to information, and allows students to learn at their own pace. Digital tools can make lessons more engaging and interactive.
However, there are also drawbacks. Technology can reduce focus, encourage multitasking, and widen the gap between students with strong digital skills and those who struggle. I have seen many students who use devices daily but still lack essential digital literacy. Technology can also make learning feel rushed or fragmented when not used thoughtfully.

Analysis

Research helps explain why technology has both positive and negative effects. Prensky (2001) argued that young people are “digital natives” who naturally think and learn differently because they grew up with technology. However, later research strongly challenges this idea. Kirschner and De Bruyckere (2017) show that the digital native concept is a myth and that young people are not automatically skilled with technology. Their work demonstrates that frequent technology use does not equal digital competence, which matches what I observe in real classrooms.

They also explain that multitasking which is common in technology-rich environments reduces learning performance because the brain switches tasks rather than doing them simultaneously. This helps explain why studying with multiple tabs open or checking notifications often leads to poorer concentration and memory.

Other educational research supports this view. Hattie (2009) found that technology alone does not improve achievement; its impact depends on how it is used and whether it supports strong teaching strategies. Selwyn (2016) also argues that technology in education should be approached critically, recognising both its potential and its limitations. Together, these studies suggest that technology is most effective when used purposefully and when students receive explicit digital literacy instruction.

Conclusion

Reflecting on this topic helped me understand that technology is neither fully positive nor fully negative. Its impact depends on intentional use, clear guidance, and strong digital literacy skills. I realised that assumptions about young people being naturally skilled with technology are misleading and can prevent educators from providing the support students actually need.

Action Plan

I will be more mindful of how I use technology in my own learning, especially avoiding unnecessary multitasking. As a future educator, I will focus on teaching digital literacy explicitly rather than assuming students already know what to do. I will also aim to use technology purposefully choosing tools that genuinely enhance learning rather than using them for the sake of it.